Would like to give an overview of DFX and DFMA before we get into DFA-index.
DFX is Design for Excellence; DFMA is Design for Assembly and Manufacturing.
DFMA is predominantly used in Manufacturing industry to keep the product cost minimal through various improvement through design changes and process optimization.
While Developing Product: We could use dFMEA, DFR (Reliability)
While High level design: We could use DFT (Testability)
During Physical design: DFA (Assembly), DFF (Fabrication)
During Prototype: DFM (Manufacturing)
With this high level overview, we shall narrow down to DFA versus DFM, which are commonly compared in Manufacturing terms
DFA Index:
This indicates level of easiness to assemble a component.
It is used to Measure Assembly Efficiency
DFA Index is an Integral metric in DFA Method.
Formula:
Where, Nm = Minimum number of slides (Theoretical)
tm = Minimum Assembly time (per part)
ts = Total Assembly time (Estimated)
For Example:
If Total time to assemble is 500s, with 9 parts and if Minimum assembly time is 50s.
Then DFA Index = 90
Larger the Value of DFA Index, more efficient is the Process
This is mainly used to Analyze the data, which could give clarity to take further actions,
"Part Elimination", "Redesign of Specific Parts"...
There are various software tools and applications available for performing DFA Analysis.
DFMA, DFA10 are few software's.
Applications of DFA Index:
DFA indicator is a good indicator of Assembly efficiency and this index could be used to analyze the data. Decision based on data analysis could lead to Fewer Parts or Simplified Assembly which could have the following benefits.
Explaining DFA from DMAIC methodology preceptive:
Define: Collecting product information and identifying opportunities for improvement
Measure: Measuring current Assembly time and cost. Calculating DFA Index (Assembly efficiency)
Analyze: Analyzing results to determine various complexities of product assembly
Improve: Improve efficiency of assembly by reducing number of parts or by reducing/changing part types
Control: Continue with best practices and follow DFA process improvement Cycle