Q 634. What is Process Benchmarking? How does it help in project identification in business excellence?

 

Note for website visitors -

• This platform hosts two weekly questions, one on Tuesday and the other on Friday. 
• All previous questions can be found here: https://www.benchmarksixsigma.com/forum/lean-six-sigma-business-excellence-questions/. 
• To participate in the current question, please visit the forum homepage at https://www.benchmarksixsigma.com/forum/.
• The question will be open until Tuesday or Friday at 5 PM Indian Standard Time, depending on the launch day. 
• Responses will not be visible until they are reviewed, and only non-plagiarised answers with less than 5-10% plagiarism will be approved. 
• If you are unsure about plagiarism, please check your answer using a plagiarism checker tool such as https://smallseotools.com/plagiarism-checker/ before submitting. 
• All correct answers shall be published, and the top-rated answer will be displayed first. The author will receive an honorable mention in our Business Excellence dictionary at https://www.benchmarksixsigma.com/forum/business-excellence-dictionary-glossary/ along with the related term.

• Some people seem to be using AI platforms to find forum answers. This is a risky approach as AI responses are error prone as our questions are application-oriented (they are never straightforward). Have a look at this funny example - https://www.benchmarksixsigma.com/forum/topic/39458-using-ai-to-respond-to-forum-questions/

• We also use an AI content detector at https://crossplag.com/ai-content-detector/. Only answers with less than 15-20% AI-generated content will be approved.

PROCESS BENCHMARKING FOR BUSINESS EXCELLENCE

 

Process Benchmarking is a methodology in which we compare two processes over performance, just to identify, the scope of improvement in each process resulting in implementing best of best practices among the process resulting in better output or performance. 

 

This has always been the best methodology adopted, to improve, by companies within same industry, having more or less, same type of process. One process can be executed by different companies in different way, hence resulting in different results.

 

So, to reduce time and effort in identification where we are lagging behind, industries started process benchmarking with the competitors available in the market. By this way, they were able to identify the shortcomings in their process and improve the same by benchmarking it with the best solution available and implemented by competition. 

 

For Example, a company "XYZ" takes 1 hour to complete a process. By comparing it to a similar company "ZYX" of the same industry, it was found that it completes the same process in 45 minutes only. This means it takes 15 minutes more by XYZ to complete that process when comapred to ZYX. With this benchmark in place, XYZ can make improvements similar to company ZYX to reduce the time to 45minutes. 

 

Benefits Of Process Benchmarking

1. Helps understand your current position.
2. Enables making improvements that matter.
3. Encourages planning and aligns goals.
4. Helps outlining roles clearly.

Stages in Process Benchmarking

1. Define Focus : Define a tightly focused subject and choose an issue which is critical to the organization’s success.
2. Select Benchmarking Partners : Identification and selection of organizations that excel in the process.
3. Gather Data and Information : Collect data of organization selected available in form of products/schemes/resourses in market.
4. Analyse and Compare : Compare your data with above collected data and identify the gaps in practices.
5. Set Performance Target : Set goals as per above gap, to come at par or surpas them. 
6. Develop Action Plan : Develop action plans which will meet above goal setting. 
7. Implement and Monitor : Implement the actions and monitor result to meet the expectations.
8. Learn and Iterate : Learn form above activities and repeat for continous improvement.

 

 

 

 

Project Identification Made Easy

Process Benchmarking helps in project identification in a very easy way, as by comparing your data with others in the market, we get a very clear picture of our shortcomings. These are the areas where we have to improve and take projects. This methodology helps us in reducing time and area of improvement in measure phase, as we specifically identify the areas where we are lagging behind. Also, this helps us in getting solutions quickly as better performer has already implemented these solutions. 

 

To conclude, it is very clear that Process Benchmarking is a very efficient tool for analysing your performance against that of industry and it very clearly reflects the areas that needs improvement. Thereafter helping in identification of areas to take improvement projects with focus.

 

 

Organizations have long understood the value of comparing themselves to industry leaders through benchmarking. This practice allows them to assess their position and identify areas of opportunity. While traditional benchmarking looks at products and performance, process benchmarking takes a more detailed approach by examining the internal processes that drive success.

 

For example, imagine examining your procurement process and comparing its efficiency and effectiveness with those of other performing companies. Process benchmarking helps uncover comparable metrics e.g. in cycle times, cost structures, or even policies. This analysis not only reveals gaps but also helps in identifying impactful projects that can propel an organization toward its goals of business excellence.

 

Now lets delve into how process benchmarking aids in project identification:

• Identifying Processes with Gaps: Benchmarking serves as a tool that highlights performance differences between your processes and those of industry leaders. These gaps/opportunities for improvement prompt projects aimed at addressing inefficiencies and achieving gains. For instance, if it is discovered that your procurement process is falling behind competitors, it could spark a project to streamline it, potentially saving resources and strengthening supplier relationships.
• Prioritizing Projects: The data obtained from benchmarking goes beyond being informative – it becomes strategic, in nature. When comparing the advantages of improvement projects (e.g. savings, efficiencies and customer satisfaction) with the necessary resources you can prioritize initiatives that bring the most significant value.
• Establishing Goals and Objectives: Benchmarking data provides a foundation for setting attainable project goals. By studying how industry leaders define success in processes you can establish targets for key performance indicators (KPIs) and align your project objectives with the pursuit of excellence and what is realistically achievable.
• Promoting Innovation and Best Practices: Examining benchmarked processes goes beyond identifying problems; it also involves discovering solutions. Analyzing how industry leaders tackle challenges exposes you to innovative approaches, tools and techniques. You can directly incorporate this knowledge into your projects to inspire creativity and drive improvement initiatives. Cross-industry examples also hold great potential when looking at process methods. 
• Developing a Solid Business Case for Excellence: Securing buy-in and resources for improvement projects can sometimes be challenging. Again, benchmarking data comes to the rescue. By demonstrating the benefits of proposed projects and their alignment with strategy/best practices, you can build a compelling argument for allocating resources and gaining support to bring your improvement initiatives to fruition.

Benchmarking processes is not a fix that happens once; it is a journey of continuous improvement, for your organization. When you systematically compare your processes to industry peers you can strategically identify areas that need improvement, define projects, stay competitive, and drive your organization towards achieving business excellence.

Process Benchmarking is comparing and analyzing your business processes with those processes that are considered the best practices in the industry.
Benchmarking can benefit any industry or business and of any size. It can help identify and evaluate the performance and areas of improvement. Conducting benchmarking process accurately and with the appropriate data set is essential to meaningful comparisons. Data is picked up from direct competitors along with industry standard best practices to determine how well your projects can meet the desired goals or objectives.

The 3 types of benchmarking in project management are Internal, External and Competitive.

Process Benchmarking is a technique of generating solutions. It is used when the focus is on improving detailed critical processes and operations. Partners are sought either internally or externally from best practice organizations that do similar work or deliver comparable services by selecting the problem which we want to solve in the process, then by mapping the actual present process. Next is to check and find out which are the companies or competitors doing the same type of business and doing better, then planning for the benchmark visit in the industries selected by the above process. The final step is to analyze the process of benchmark company & good points in own process, finalize the targets.

Process Benchmarking:

 

Process Benchmarking can be defined as measuring your process performance against the best-in-class processes by gathering data, analyzing it, determining how the best-in-class processes achieve those performance levels, and utilizing the information thus gathered as a basis to improve your own process.

 

The best-in-class processes that are being benchmarked could be either internal processes within the organization or external processes outside the organization.  Benchmarking relies solely on your capability to gather reliable data of the best-in-class processes that you are intending to benchmark via appropriate benchmark methodology.

 

Benchmarking can be done via best practices sharing forums, partnerships that allow both parties to learn from each other known as collaborative benchmarking.  One could also subscribe to “exchange service” that collects benchmark information and makes it available for a fee.  Sometimes, processes of other industry provide valuable insights that can be implemented in our process to achieve breakthrough improvements.  This is called as functional benchmarking.

 

Most of the benchmarking processes undergo the following phases:

 

 

 

 

Use of Process Benchmarking for Project Identification:

 

The following benchmarking scenarios can be a source of various projects:

 

1).          Efficiency Issues with the Current Processes:  The existing process is producing way too many defects along with lead time challenges resulting in quite a few client escalations.  Benchmarking it with similar best-in-class processes that are more efficient can help narrow the gap between current and future performance.  The lead time challenges can be addressed via Lean Projects and a DMAIC project may assist in reducing the defects.

 

2).          Challenging the Status Quo:  The organization wants to reassess how the Critical to Acceptance parameters of key deliverables of their processes fare vis-a-vis their competitors via competitive benchmarking.  Customer surveys can provide a high-level overview followed by a more granular approach such as QFDs to further drill it down.  Common suppliers can also provide valuable insights.  Any significant gaps in the Critical to Acceptance parameters that might pose a potential risk to customer retention could be a candidate for a DMAIC project.

 

3).          Adoption of Emerging Technologies/Digital Transformation:  The organization intends to improve the AI penetration in their processes and is looking to benchmark processes of potential organizations that have successfully used GenAI to improve process efficiency.  QFD or Design Thinking might assist here, and it could be a candidate for a Process Re-Engineering/DMADV project.

 

Conclusion:  Despite being a well-known tool for best practice sharing, benchmarking should not restrict an organization to a level it has attained post benchmarking.  Since the best-in-class process that is being studied, is there for everyone to see and emulate, it is hard to imagine how it would provide someone a competitive advantage. It might be a good idea to use benchmarking as a short-term solution to bring your services and products to a level that they are comparable with other players in the same industry but in the long term, the benchmarking process should be flexible enough to accommodate new and innovative ideas built upon the benchmarked best practices. If everyone keeps benchmarking each other, it would lead to stagnation across industries, predisposing them for eventual replacement by outside innovators.

Process Benchmarking : Process benchmarking is the exercise to measure the quality and performance of a business processes and then comparing or analyzing those measured parameters with other business processes which are considered as best practices in the similar industry. Process benchmarking can be internal, external or competitive.

Purpose : The main purpose of process benchmarking is to improve the current business performances like process efficiency, productivity or quality by learning from other best practices and by implementing strategies to minimize the identified gaps.

Benefits : It helps to understand where the existing business processes stands compared to others or competitors, which gives us the awareness on scope of improvement also guides to set clear goals, thus drives the continuous improvement to gin competitive advantage.

 

Project identification in Business Excellence through Process Benchmarking :
Business excellence is the initiative which many of the organization follows to evolve best practices and managing business processes in effective manner to achieve more sustainable results. It helps to drive productivity improvement, sustainability and competitiveness also. To achieve those outstanding results, it is very important to understand how and on what parameters other organizations are achieving higher performance than our company. There comes the importance of process benchmarking, which helps us to know how much better we can perform and improve the exiting processes by selecting right projects on the identified gaps and implementing the learnings.

Right project selection is very important so that company resources will be rightly utilized to ensure good returns and achieve goals. To identify the right projects there can be several types of benchmarking, like Internal, which helps to evaluate and compare internal processes, thus establishing same standard company wide. Next is External benchmarking, which is the method of collecting and evaluating metrices from external sources like other similar industries, those are performing better than us in some manner, and we can take projects to improve on those deliverables by establishing industry standard. There can be also Competitive Process benchmarking, which helps in identifying right projects to achieve the parameters on those our business process lagging from competitors, thus organization will get the competitive advantage by improving performances, products and services. So to make the business excellence journey successful, benchmarking is vey important in terms of right project selection.

 

The process of evaluating and contrasting your business's methods with those regarded as best practices in the industry is known as process benchmarking. In order to provide meaningful comparisons during process benchmarking, it is imperative that the processes being compared have similar characteristics. Enhancing current business procedures is the main objective of process benchmarking, which enables your company to successfully compete with market leaders.

Advantages:

1.      Recognizing Current Position: This aids in determining how your business procedure compares to others.

2.      Enabling Improvements: Process benchmarking establishes standards for improvement and offers precise goals to be met.

3.      Promoting Planning: A well-defined route promotes planning and harmonizes objectives for the expansion of a corporation.

Steps in Project identification:

1.      Identify Success Metrics:

It is important to understand success metrics to identify a project. Proper strategic planning and thorough research is required when benchmarking a project. The goal is to identify valuable data related to a specific objective which includes Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) that measure project success. By understanding these metrics, we gain insights into what works and what doesn’t.

2.      Comparison:

The benchmarking process involves comparing your project’s performance data with external benchmarks like other best in class projects, competitors, or industry standards. This helps in understanding the what the project lacks and what areas can be improved.

3.      Measurement:

Benchmarking allows you to define and measure project performance accurately at any stage whether it’s the beginning, middle, or end of a project, you can assess progress effectively. This accurate measurement helps track success and identify deviations.

4. Types of Benchmarking:

                                                    i.     Internal Benchmarking: Compare processes within your organization.

                                                   ii.     Management Benchmarking: Compare leadership practices across different locations.

                                                  iii.     Functional Benchmarking: Focus on specific functions like software development, product design, marketing campaigns etc. to improve processes.

Real life example:

1.      Iterations in Product Design:- Examining the approaches taken by different businesses or sectors in terms of product design, prototyping, and iteration cycles. Product development can be streamlined, and creative design techniques can be found through benchmarking.

2.      Marketing Campaign Initiatives: - assessing marketing initiatives from various companies. Businesses can improve their own strategies and learn from successful campaigns by comparing metrics like as return on investment, conversion rates, reach, engagement, and conversion rates.

 

 

Businesses are always striving for improving their products, services and performance. However, it is difficult to assess the current status without having a standard to compare.

Through benchmarking, any business can compare itself against a standard/ best-in-class.

 

There are different types of benchmarking for different purposes. Some types of benchmarking below:

1.         Competitive benchmarking

2.         Functional benchmarking

3.         Strategic benchmarking

4.         Product benchmarking

5.         Performance benchmarking

6.         Process benchmarking

We will focus on Process Benchmarking and try to understand this further.

 

Process Benchmarking- In process benchmarking, an identified business process is compared to similar business process to gain valuable insights that can help improve the identified process.

The identified process can be compared to similar internal process, or with competitor or with similar process outside of the industry.

Example:

·       Internal: Comparison of processes at different factories within the same organization. Factory A has process defect percentage of 87% against benchmark factory B having 95% process defects. By analyzing the process and data of factory B- factory A can compare its own process and identify areas of improvement. Factory A can implement best practices from Factory B. Factory A can also chose to replicate the entire process at Factory B.  This way Factory A can avoid a lot of rework and increase efficiency.

 

·       Competitor: Comparison of competitor’s warranty claim processing process

Competitor has claim resolution time of 2 days against 7 days in organization X.  Hence, X has a gap of 5 days against benchmark.  If X can get details of competitor’s process and identify differences in their own process, then X can improve significantly. This may also help them gain and retain more customers.

 

·       Similar process outside of the industry: Comparison of invoicing process of IT industry to manufacturing industry. It takes manufacturing organization XYZ- 7 days complete the customer invoicing process vs 1 day in IT organization ABC. Process benchmarking can help XYZ improve invoicing process time by 6 days. This can potentially help XYZ to get paid upto 6 days faster.

 

 

 

Steps in Process benchmarking:

 

·       Define Objectives- Clearly define the objectives of benchmarking. Identify specific processes or areas you want to improve and set measurable goals.

·       Select Benchmark Partners- Choose benchmark partners that excel in the areas you aim to improve.

·       Collect Data- Gather relevant data on your processes and those of the benchmark partners. This may include process steps, timelines, costs, quality metrics, and other relevant performance indicators.

·       Analyse and Compare- Analyze the collected data to identify gaps and differences between your processes and those of the benchmark partners. Understand the reasons behind the superior performance of the benchmark partners.

·       Identify Solutions- Identify solutions for the identified gaps. These could be simply replication of best practices employed by the benchmark partners or may need detailed analysis and solution design.

·       Implement Changes- Develop an action plan based on the identified gaps and best practices. Implement changes in your processes.

·       Measure and Monitor- Establish performance metrics to monitor the impact of changes. Regularly measure and compare your updated processes against the benchmark to ensure ongoing improvement.

 

How process benchmarking helps in project identification?

Process benchmarking can help in project identification in following ways.

1.     Identifying areas of improvement- Through process benchmarking, organizations can understand the current state and identify gaps in comparison to industry leaders. These identified gaps can become potential project opportunities to enhance processes and improve performance.

2.     Measurement and Quantification of opportunities- The comparison with the standard helps in having clear measures and KPIs of current performance and gaps. This helps selecting appropriate metrics and in clear goal setting in the project identification stage.

3.     Building project charter- The insights gained from benchmarking provide a solid foundation for business case during project identification. Leaders can assess the viability and potential success of projects based on proven practices observed in benchmarked organizations. Benchmark partner can provide significant information on time, resources, feasibility, risks of the project which would be crucial elements in project charter.

4.     Prioritizing projects- Projects can be prioritized based on the impact on the overall organizational performance and alignment with strategic objectives. Benchmark partners can also provide insights on benefits, ease of implementation and effort required. These elements can help in prioritizing the identified projects.

 

Other benefits of process benchmarking:

1.     Learning from the leaders

2.     Boosts innovation and creativity.

3.     Increases employee engagement and sparks new ideas

4.     Gain advantage from quick replication of best practices

5.     Develop collaborative relationship with benchmark partner

Very informative answers from all. The best answer has been given by Shubham Chamoli. Well done. 

 

Other answers are a must read as well.